Skip to main content

Table 2 Prevalence and severity of youth criminogenic risk factors among violent offenders and nonviolent offenders

From: Constellations of youth criminogenic factors associated with young adult violent criminal behavior

Domain 1. history of criminal behavior

Min–max

Violent offenders (n = 146)

Nonviolent offenders (n = 241)

χ2

p

n

%

none

% moderate

% severe

n missing

n

%

none

% moderate

% severe

n missing

Property offense, ever

0–1

143

2.8

n/a

97.2

3

240

25.8

n/a

74.2

1

38.16

< .001

Violent offense, ever

0–1

142

1.4

n/a

98.6

4

240

25.8

n/a

74.2

1

57.75

< .001

Sexual offense, ever

0–1

142

88.7

n/a

11.3

4

238

95.8

n/a

4.2

3

15.05

.002

Arson, ever

0–1

145

86.9

n/a

13.1

1

239

92.5

n/a

7.5

2

2.61

.106

Offenses: mainly solo (0) or in a group (1)

0–1

124

21.8

n/a

78.2

26

223

37.2

n/a

62.8

17

8.08

.004

 

Min–max

n

Mean (sd)

n missing

Min–max

n

Mean (sd)

n missing

F

p

Age of first nonviolent offense

6–17

135

12.8 (2.25)

11

7–17

187

13.6 (1.98)

54

10.47

.001

Age of first violent behavior

4–19

128

13.8 (2.55)

18

6–18

168

14.1 (2.00)

63

.90

.343

Domain 2. Upbringing and environment

Min–max

n

%

none

% moderate

% severe

n missing

n

%

none

% moderate

% severe

n missing

χ2

p

Out of home placement (due to self)

0–1

145

77.2

n/a

22.8

1

241

77.2

n/a

22.8

–

.00

1.000

Out of home placement (due to parents)

0–1

145

89.7

n/a

10.3

1

241

92.5

n/a

7.5

–

.96

.328

Early age of onset of problem behavior

0–2

144

0.0

53.5

46.5

2

240

4.2

65.8

30.0

1

15.04

.001

Availability and accessibility of parents

0–2

145

30.3

46.2

23.4

1

235

28.5

53.6

17.9

6

2.47

.291

Adoption problems

0–2

146

97.3

2.1

0.7

–

240

94.6

5.0

0.4

1

2.42

.299

Peer rejection

0–2

136

68.4

24.3

7.4

10

212

67.9

25.5

6.6

29

.19

.943

(inconsistent) Parenting skills

0–2

140

5.7

35.0

59.3

6

227

15.0

42.3

42.7

14

12.50

.002

Authority problems

0–2

143

11.9

41.3

46.9

3

228

18.4

45.6

36.0

13

5.39

.068

Involvement with criminal peers

0–2

143

2.8

42.7

54.5

3

218

40.4

42.2

17.4

23

84.85

< .001

Criminal family members

0–2

137

32.1

13.9

54.0

9

216

68.1

11.1

20.8

25

47.91

< .001

Physical abuse by parents

0–2

127

53.5

22.8

23.6

19

206

55.8

22.3

21.8

35

.19

.908

Physical abuse by others

0–2

141

82.3

13.5

4.3

5

234

73.9

19.2

6.8

7

3.50

.174

Neglect

0–2

137

64.2

24.1

11.7

9

226

72.6

19.9

7.5

15

3.17

.205

Sexual abuse by parents

0–2

142

100.0

–

–

4

237

99.2

–

0.8

4

.13

.715

Sexual abuse by others

0–2

142

95.8

2.8

1.4

4

237

97.5

0.8

1.7

4

2.17

.339

Domestic violence

0–2

112

58.9

15.2

25.9

36

200

66.0

8.5

25.5

41

3.51

.173

History of prior youth care

0–2

145

3.4

15.9

80.7

1

241

5.4

17.0

77.6

–

.92

.632

Dysfunctional family (disrupted hierarchy)

0–2

140

50.0

25.0

25.0

6

222

74.3

13.1

12.6

19

22.32

< .001

Escalating family situations

0–2

132

81.1

11.4

7.6

14

228

81.6

12.3

6.1

13

.32

.852

Truancy/school drop-out

0–2

141

15.6

24.1

60.3

5

234

13.7

19.7

66.7

7

1.60

.449

Parental substance abuse

0–2

133

78.9

6.0

15.0

13

212

69.8

11.3

18.9

29

4.10

.129

Parental mental health problems

0–2

124

77.4

12.9

9.7

22

207

70.0

16.4

13.5

34

2.17

.339

Parental somatic problems

0–1

114

52.6

n/a

47.4

32

217

71.9

n/a

28.1

24

11.39

.001

Learning problems

0–2

139

71.2

24.5

4.3

7

219

75.8

19.6

4.6

22

1.16

.560

Threat to end up in prostitution

0–2

146

98.6

1.4

–

–

238

99.6

0.4

–

3

.18

.67

Avoiding supervision/escape

0–2

145

17.2

77.2

5.5

1

235

40.9

57.9

1.3

6

26.42

< .001

Domain 3. Offense situation and drugs

Min–max

n

%

none

% moderate

% severe

n missing

n

%

none

% moderate

% severe

n missing

χ2

p

During medicine abstinence/psychosis

0–2

143

98.6

0.7

0.7

3

238

100.0

–

–

3

3.94

.140

Under influence of alcohol

0–1

100

62.0

n/a

38.0

46

218

87.2

n/a

12.8

23

24.87

< .001

Under influence of drugs

0–1

71

63.4

n/a

36.6

75

204

90.7

n/a

9.3

37

26.73

< .001

Against familiar person

0–2

140

67.1

25.0

7.9

6

238

79.0

13.0

8.0

3

8.90

.012

Sexually related, in search of a victim

0–2

146

99.3

0.7

–

1

240

100.0

–

–

1

.06

.801

Domain 4. Psychological functions

Min–max

n

%

none

% moderate

% severe

n missing

n

%

none

% moderate

% severe

n missing

χ2

p

Lack of empathy

0–2

130

9.2

60.0

30.8

16

196

46.4

36.2

17.3

45

50.10

< .001

Impaired conscience development

0–2

134

0.7

56.0

43.3

12

203

18.2

65.0

16.7

38

43.77

< .001

Ego-strength/susceptible (to peers)

0–2

139

12.9

57.6

29.5

7

183

16.9

57.4

25.7

58

1.25

.536

Low impulse control

0–2

131

11.5

38.2

50.4

15

208

22.6

49.5

27.9

43

18.88

< .001

Lack of problem awareness/problem insight

0–2

133

2.3

48.1

49.6

13

213

28.2

46.5

25.4

28

44.15

< .001

 

Min–max

n

Mean (sd)

n missing

n

Min–max

Mean (sd)

n missing

F

p

Total IQ

54–121

96

82.4 (13.8)

50

131

51–129

87.2 (13.5)

110

6.93

.009

Domain 5. Psychopathology

Min–max

n

%

none

% moderate

% severe

n missing

n

%

none

% moderate

% severe

n missing

χ2

p

Addiction problems: gambling

0–2

128

98.4

0.8

0.8

18

229

98.3

1.3

0.4

12

.38

.825

Addiction problems: alcohol

0–2

127

66.9

27.6

5.5

19

219

76.3

19.2

4.6

22

3.64

.162

Addiction problems: drugs

0–2

134

26.1

61.2

12.7

13

216

40.3

46.8

13.0

25

8.06

.018

ADHD/hyperactivity

0–2

141

75.9

16.3

7.8

5

222

86.5

7.2

6.3

19

8.11

.017

Anxiety disorder

0–2

138

93.5

5.1

1.4

8

233

92.7

5.6

1.7

8

.09

.958

Depressive disorder

0–2

136

85.3

14.0

0.7

10

222

74.8

18.0

7.2

19

9.46

.009

Neurological problems

0–2

135

97.0

3.0

–

11

225

96.0

3.6

0.4

16

1.04

.595

Development personality disorder type B

0–2

108

25.0

28.7

46.3

48

201

57.2

27.9

14.9

40

42.59

< .001

Feelings of hostility/agressiveness

0–2

142

97.2

2.8

–

4

232

98.7

0.9

0.4

9

3.00

.224

Autism spectrum disorder

0–2

144

97.2

2.1

0.7

2

233

94.8

2.6

2.6

8

2.10

.350

Psychotic symptoms

0–2

142

95.8

3.5

0.7

4

235

96.6

1.3

2.1

6

3.29

.193

Sadism

0–2

146

94.5

5.5

–

2

237

98.7

0.8

0.4

4

8.47

.014

Sexually deviant behavior

0–2

143

88.8

8.4

2.8

3

227

95.6

3.1

1.3

14

6.26

.044

Pedosexual behavior

0–2

146

98.6

1.4

–

–

238

100.0

–

–

3

1.17

.280

Domain 6. Social and relational

Min–max

n

%

none

% moderate

% severe

n missing

n

%

none

% moderate

% severe

n missing

χ2

p

Negative affect/attitude

0–2

140

42.9

40.7

16.4

6

225

66.7

25.8

7.6

16

20.81

< .001

Emotional support

0–2

136

64.7

33.1

2.2

10

233

70.8

24.0

5.2

8

5.00

.082

Total social network

0–2

142

12.0

78.9

9.2

4

234

45.3

50.4

4.3

7

45.14

< .001

Secundary social network

0–2

140

2.1

57.1

40.7

6

235

28.1

51.1

20.9

6

44.94

< .001

Social skills

0–2

136

47.8

37.5

14.7

10

217

59.0

32.7

8.3

24

5.66

.049